Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Analysis of Obama's Speech on Rev. Wright's Comments.

I just finished watching Barack Obama's fabulous speech addressing not only Rev. Wright's outrageous comments but also race and poverty in America in general. Here is the video of the speech:
He raised the bar to address all races including whites who have faced hardships that are just as much about poverty as race because poverty is an equal opportunity oppressor--regardless of race. Obama could have walked away from this opportunity to heal these wounds and just take the safe road but Obama is not the typical politician. He has a way of broadening the conversation to include everyone so that as a community we can all recognize that no one is perfect and that we can come together despite our environmental conditionings.

Obama has time and time again walked fearlessly straight into the face of issues that most of America is squeamish to speak about. He didn't just simply condemn the Rev's comments but went one step further and eloquently said that he also disagrees with the context of said comments that hint that America can not change. Such a statement wonderfully underlined why his campaign is centered upon bringing change, not only to the government but to the overall consciousness of America. Here is one of the most poignant parts of the speech that I found:

He had earlier used a similar theme in acknowledging that some people would be disappointed with his rebuke of Wright. “Given my background, my politics, and my professed values and ideals, there will no doubt be those for whom my statements of condemnation are not enough,’’ he said. Instead, Obama cast that path as politically expedient.

“I can no more disown him than I can disown the black community,” Obama said. “I can no more disown him than I can my white grandmother — a woman who helped raise me, a woman who sacrificed again and again for me, a woman who loves me as much as she loves anything in this world, but a woman who once confessed her fear of black men who passed by her on the street, and who on more than one occasion has uttered racial or ethnic stereotypes that made me cringe.”

TPJ: For those of us who are religious, have you ever disagreed with something that your pastor, cleric, rabbi or monk has said? I know I have as a Buddhist. I don't agree with everything that I have heard said in the Buddhist community but I don't cast off Buddhism as a whole, nor my teacher. For the non-religious, have you ever disagreed with your family members over stupid statements before? Of course but most of us usually don't disown them unless of course they berate us on a daily basis and abuse us in other ways. However, most of the time offensive or insulting statements from our family members come from places of ignorance of just plain stupidity. And who amongst us hasn't said something dumb ourselves?

This is because we are all imperfect and say bone-headed things from time to time and if we all separated ourselves from those we sometimes disagree with, no one would have any relationship with anyone else!! We would live in a world where everyone would be isolated from others and I am willing to forgive Geraldine Ferraro's comments so that we can move forward back to the issues that matter most. Obama always finds a way to put aside the divisions of the past and bring us back to the issues at hand and you mean to tell me that he is not ready to be president which is a job that requires having the ability to unite others like no other job in America? He tipifies the phrase, "Cooler heads prevail."

Speaking of that issue I think it is important to speak more about how calm and collected Obama is no matter the situation. Even in the face of these comments from his paster he is able to lower the temperature and address the underlying issues at hand instead of snapping back in anger at his critics like so many politicians have done and do. He has the steady hand that is needed to deal with the tough issues that a president faces. I can not see him losing his temper with other leaders like John McCain and George Bush have done time and time again.

Barack understands the importance of keeping the dialog on a respectful and hopeful level. His ability to bring new people to the political process and reach out to independents tells me that he would be more than capable and talented in bringing political leaders of other countries together to change the conversation. I want a leader that the world can respect and admire as someone that they can work with and Barack is the best candidate between Clinton and McCain to do just that. After 8 long years of being embarrassed of my president I would be proud to see a President Obama as our representative to the world. I can think of no other politician on the political stage here in America that is better to be our number one ambassador than Barack Obama.

One more thing about the controversial Rev. Wright, I find it breath-takingly hypocritical of the right-wing slamming Obama for being connected to this pastor when their politicians have been proudly embracing outlandish and offensive pastors for decades. At least Obama clearly has over and over distanced himself from the comments of Rev. Wright that are offensive. It seems that many of the right stay silent when conservative pastor after pastor say equally as offensive things because they don't want to alienate a large voting block in their party.

Here are a few other great snippets from the speech:

-But race is an issue that I believe this nation cannot afford to ignore right now. We would be making the same mistake that Reverend Wright made in his offending sermons about America - to simplify and stereotype and amplify the negative to the point that it distorts reality.

-
The profound mistake of Reverend Wright's sermons is not that he spoke about racism in our society. It's that he spoke as if our society was static; as if no progress has been made; as if this country - a country that has made it possible for one of his own members to run for the highest office in the land and build a coalition of white and black; Latino and Asian, rich and poor, young and old -- is still irrevocably bound to a tragic past. But what we know -- what we have seen - is that America can change. That is true genius of this nation. What we have already achieved gives us hope - the audacity to hope - for what we can and must achieve tomorrow.

TPJ: Meanwhile, Iraq is heating up again with a series of bombings over the last week that have left hundreds of Iraqis dead and a handful of our soldiers killed as well.

---End of Transmission---

9 comments:

Riverwolf said...

Haven't heard the speech but hope to catch up later.

I'm still having a problem with why Obama has been at this particular church for 20 years. In my past, I've been to some fire-and-brimstone churches, churches that got real political--but I never stayed. It's like if today I, as a gay man, attended a church where the pastor regularly condemned gay people. Uh, hello?

The church I currently attend is great, and I can't ever imagine my pastor going into such a rant. There are other ways to get a point across. But to your point about not agreeing with everyone, sure, there are things my pastor says that I don't agree with. But they're theological points, not blanket statements against the U.S. government or entire races of people. Yet it's those relatively minor theological points that are leading me to question how much longer I'll remain a member.

With so many churches out there, Obama could go anywhere. I refuse to believe he was unable to find a church that was more in line with his true beliefs and demeanor. It actually makes me question how seriously he takes his Christian faith. Has he been asleep during the sermons?

When things no longer seem to work, we do have to consider leaving them behind. I am weaning myself away from Christianity because of the crazy things done and said in God's name. And I no longer believe in the basics. If I stay, I don't feel I would have any integrity.

James said...

Riverwolf:

Well I can understand where you are coming from. I think that he wants to give his pastor another chance while making it clear that he does not in the least agree his more extreme comments.

I'm not trying to defend the pastor's comments but to admonish but forgive is the Christian way.

I hope the Rev. learned his lesson and will calm down and work to over-come his hang-ups.

That being said, I hope that we all can work toward over-coming our own hang-ups.

Tom said...

I think that Barack is aware of Pastor Wright's background having grown up in fervent racism of the 50s and 60s, and that he has had an opportunity to see the pastor in the full spectrum of his lovingkindness and venomousness.

I certainly know people who have problems and beliefs that I don't share and would condemn, but that there are other aspects of their personalities that I have come to cherish. Sometimes, you just come to 'know' somebody so well they become a permanent fixture in your life.

For this to happen to Barack Obama is praiseworthy. He is a brilliant and accepting man. Obama is not someone who won't be thinking for himself as president. He's not going to be anybody's puppet, so there is no reason to worry about Pastor Wright's influence.

T&A said...

Churches are communities to many folks. Often people will attend their parish, congregation,or synagogue for reasons that have little to do with the religious or political message being thrown out out at them. Ones friends and neighbors gather at churches and the sense of community is a comfort to them.

Even as an atheist I attend AA meetings only because I enjoy seeing the friends I have there. I don't agree with the prevailing message that one needs a god to get and stay sober that is espoused there. But I do think there is a power of the group.

There are several people at these meetings that say things that annoy me to no end, so much so that if it weren't for the people I like, I'd go elsewhere.

James said...

T&A:

There are several people at these meetings that say things that annoy me to no end, so much so that if it weren't for the people I like, I'd go elsewhere.

Excellent point. As long as there are more people that you like in any organization it's easier to put up with the cranks.

The world is full of jackasses and just because we don't confront everyone of them doesn't mean that we agree with them.

Sometimes it's better to just let people go off and make a fool of themselves. Most people understand that you can't blame everyone in an organization for the stupid actions of a few people or one in Rev. Wright's case.

Tom said...

Understood, James. But the impression shouldn't be made that those are Barack's sentiments towards Wright.

James said...

Tom:

Point taken. I agree with you.

Scarlet said...

FYI - In the black community - church isn't just church - it's the start of the week, your family reunion, your dating pool, your babysitters, your faith connection, your job security, etc., etc., etc. So for Mr. Obama to attend the same church for 20 years, he's engaging in a black cultural benchmark. He has engaged with a steady hand in the most divisive of issues....and has allowed for some key adjustments in tone with this speech.

That speech solidified my decision.

James said...

Scarlet:

Yes, you're right. There is so much more to the black church experience. Most of it is very good.